Jackie Brown (1997)

Tarantino's style is suited to Leonard's -- he takes the novel and makes it into a Quentin Tarantino movie. As a director, he loves to keep his audience a little in the dark so that they'll work a little and meet him halfway. The most inspired sequence is a Rashomon-type three-way in which we see "the switch" three times in a row from three different points of view. Like Leonard, he has a gift for great-sounding dialogue, but he saturates Jackie Brown with it, and there's not enough plot to keep us interested. On the other hand, Tarantino's inexperience in adaptation shows. The movie is very long (2 hours and 40 minutes), and quite a lot of it is expositional and unnecessary. It's a thriller with a standard plot, and it needs to move a little faster. However, when Grier and Forester are on screen, the movie sparkles. These are unquestionably Tarantino's greatest characters, and the actors eat them up with verve. The movie also makes great use of Los Angeles. For once it looks like a real city and not just a sterilized movie set.

Note: In 1999, I chose Pulp Fiction as the movie of the decade. Two years later, I still regard it as a masterpiece and would still call it the movie of the '90s on a technical level, but I believe now that Jackie Brown is Tarantino's greatest and most accomplished film. (Similarly, I don't deny the greatness of Orson Welles' Citizen Kane, even though my favorite of his films is Chimes at Midnight.) I gave Jackie Brown a lukewarm review in 1997, but seeing it twice more I find that it's more of a slow burn in contrast to Pulp Fiction's sudden flare-up. It takes longer to sink in. Before, his characters spoke crackling dialogue and we loved listening to them. But here they have real soul. The lovely scenes between Grier and Forster especially sparkle and hum. Everyone makes mistakes, I guess, and so I've upped my rating from its original 2 1/2 out of 4 to a more deserving level. Miramax's DVD comes with a huge, wonderful gallery of trailers for most of Pam Grier and Robert Forster's films, deleted scenes, Siskel & Ebert's TV review, short documentaries, and much more.

In 2011, Lionsgate, which owns the Miramax back catalog, released Jackie Brown on Blu-Ray. Tarantino supervised the transfer, and it looks amazing. It includes all the same extras as the DVD.