Nowhere Boy (2010)

So instead, rather than a story about John Lennon, Nowhere Boy tells the story of a sad, angry Liverpool teen who lives with his aunt and begins a new relationship with his estranged mother, Julia (Anne-Marie Duff). Mimi runs a tight ship, but the good-time Julia listens to rock 'n' roll records and teaches John to play the banjo. Eventually John begins to wonder just why his mother didn't actually raise him, and the reason is presented as a secret, kept until the climactic blowout in the third act. Meanwhile, this outspoken, artistic lad meets a kid named Paul (Thomas Brodie Sangster) and starts a band. Maybe you've heard of them.

Sometimes this approach works and sometimes it doesn't. Nowhere Boy is still based on a true story, and there's only so far it can go in re-arranging the facts for dramatic impact. Not to mention that the conflict between John, his mother and his aunt really doesn't amount to much; if we were talking about just some poor, sad, ordinary boy rather than Lennon, there certainly wouldn't be a movie here. Duff and Thomas both give it their all, however, each pained and governed by their past deeds; they emerge with two superb, fully-rounded performances. Johnson (Kick-Ass) doesn't always convince as Lennon, but he at least settles on a kind of Lennonesque essence.

The movie does go a bit into the music, as Iain Softley's Backbeat (1994) did, focusing on a young, enthusiastic cover band that pays tribute to Chuck Berry and other early rockers. But Nowhere Boy saves a showstopper for its closing moments. We see a legendary recording session as John, Paul and George step up to the mike for "In Spite of All the Danger" (written by Paul and George). That song -- credited to the Quarrymen -- remained a valuable rarity for decades until it was finally released on the Beatles "Anthology" CDs. This rendition of it has a real power, and a hint of greater things to come... without actually saying anything out loud.